Where to Watch/Listen
Watch: [YouTube]
Listen: [Spotify Link]
Key Takeaways
- Boxer briefs dominate as the best all-around everyday underwear style, offering the perfect balance of support, coverage, and comfort
- Trunks (3-inch inseam) primarily work for men with slimmer builds, as they tend to ride up on guys with larger thighs
- Body type plays a massive role in which underwear styles actually work for daily wear
- Going commando creates hygiene and comfort issues that make it impractical for everyday use
- Pouch underwear provides crucial separation that prevents chafing, overheating, and discomfort
What's the best underwear style for everyday wear? It's a question every guy has an opinion on, but most have never actually thought through systematically. In this episode of Real Men Real Talk, Chris and Tilghman tackle this debate head-on, ranking every major underwear style from the traditional brief to the bold choice of going commando.
The conversation reveals something important: the underwear industry pushes certain styles heavily, but those styles don't necessarily work for most men's body types and daily lives. Here's what they discovered.
The Brief Reality: Simple But Effective
Briefs landed in the "chill" category, and for good reason. While they carry the stigma of "whitey tighties," Chris and Tilghman acknowledge that briefs have evolved significantly. The main concern? For guys with larger thighs, briefs can create too much skin-to-skin contact on the legs, leading to discomfort throughout the day.
Tilghman shares a candid childhood memory about briefs and wedgies that many will relate to, but ultimately concludes that as an adult, briefs work fine for everyday wear. They're simple, supportive, and get the job done without unnecessary complications.
The key insight here is that briefs aren't necessarily bad - they're just not optimized for every body type. If you have slimmer legs, briefs might work perfectly. If you have athletic or larger thighs, you might find yourself constantly dealing with friction and bunching.
Trunks: The European Import That Doesn't Translate
Trunks - the 3-inch inseam boxer briefs - received a harsh "falling off" rating from both hosts. Chris notes that these are everywhere in European stores and increasingly common in American big box retailers. The problem? They roll up on most guys' legs.
Tilghman found only one trunk that worked for him: the Real Men three-inch inseam with V-fly in black, which he uses specifically as a base layer under swimming trunks. For everyday wear? They're constantly riding up and requiring readjustment.
The consensus: trunks primarily work for men with slimmer builds. "There's a lot of guys that like trunks, but they tend to be on the skinnier body side," Tilghman observes. This reveals a broader issue in men's underwear - many styles are designed for one body type and marketed to everyone.
Boxer Shorts: The Nostalgic Choice That Doesn't Hold Up
Boxer shorts received the dreaded "cooked" ranking from both hosts. Despite their popularity in the early 2000s (remember those Hollister and Aeropostale boxers?), they simply don't work for active, everyday wear.
Tilghman's experience trying to wear boxers for football practice ended in severe chafing. Chris points out the hygiene concerns that come with loose-fitting boxers. "If you're a guy and you wear boxer shorts and you happen to be married, I feel bad for your wife because she's gotta wash those skid marks out of there," Tilghman says bluntly.
The fundamental issue with boxers is that they provide no support and too much fabric movement. They bunch up under pants, shift during activity, and create friction where you don't want it. While some guys appreciate the loose feel for sleeping, for everyday wear they're simply impractical.
Boxer Briefs: The Undisputed Champion
Both hosts immediately put boxer briefs in the "locked in" category - and it's easy to see why. Boxer briefs offer the perfect combination of support, coverage, and versatility. They work under different types of pants, they provide leg coverage to prevent chafing, and they keep everything secure during movement.
"In my personal opinion, the boxer brief is the bread and butter of every person who has to wear underwear on a daily basis," Chris states. The longer inseam prevents ride-up on guys with larger thighs, while the fitted design provides support without the restrictiveness of briefs.
The popularity of boxer briefs isn't just marketing - it's function meeting form. They work across different body types better than most other styles, making them the safe choice for everyday wear.
The Specialized Styles: Great for Specific Uses, Not Daily Wear
Jockstraps, thongs, and leggings all received "falling off" or "chill" rankings for everyday wear - not because they're bad, but because they're specialized pieces.
Jockstraps excel for athletic support but offer no coverage in the back, making them impractical for all-day wear. Thongs surprised both hosts by being more comfortable than expected, but the lack of coverage and specific body type requirements keep them from being daily drivers.
Leggings present fit challenges, with Tilghman noting that finding a pair that stays up properly is difficult. While the Real Men brush nylon leggings work well as a warming layer for outdoor activities, the constant readjustment needed makes them less ideal for everyday office wear.
Commando: The Freedom That Comes at a Cost
Going commando landed below "cooked" in the rankings. While some guys swear by the freedom, the practical issues are significant. Without underwear, sweat goes directly into your pants, chafing becomes a major concern, and hygiene suffers.
Chris tried going commando for several months and concluded that the moment temperatures rise, the experience becomes uncomfortable. "Maybe you love to just make your pants as gross as possible. I'm sorry, I can't get there," he says.
Tilghman shares a survival camp story where he had no choice but to go commando, resulting in chafing so severe he couldn't walk normally for a day. The takeaway? Underwear serves important functions beyond convention - it manages moisture, prevents friction, and maintains hygiene.
The Pouch Principle: Why Separation Matters
Throughout the conversation, both hosts emphasize the importance of pouch underwear - styles that provide actual separation and support rather than just fabric. Chris explains it with a memorable analogy: "Good fences make good neighbors - your junk and your legs are neighbors and they need a fence around them."
Pouch underwear addresses fundamental comfort and health issues. It prevents your anatomy from sticking to your legs in heat, reduces chafing, maintains better airflow, and keeps everything properly supported during movement. This design consideration makes more difference than the actual style (brief vs. boxer brief vs. trunk).
Many mainstream brands still don't incorporate proper pouch design, which is why guys often assume all underwear is uncomfortable or that going commando is the answer. The reality is that the right design makes all the difference.
Bringing It All Together: Know Your Body, Choose Accordingly
This ranking exercise reveals something more important than just which style wins. It shows that underwear choice should be based on your specific body type, activity level, and daily routine - not just what's popular or heavily marketed.
For most guys, boxer briefs with proper pouch support will be the winning choice for everyday wear. But if you have slimmer legs, briefs or even trunks might work perfectly. If you're highly athletic, you might incorporate jockstraps for specific activities. The key is understanding what actually works for your life rather than following trends.
The conversation also highlights the importance of quality and design. The difference between a good pair of boxer briefs and a cheap pair is significant. Features like inseam length, waistband design, fabric choice, and pouch construction all impact daily comfort. Investing in well-designed underwear isn't vanity - it's practical self-care that affects how you feel every single day.
